Fire Alarm · Troubleshooting
What Is an FDNY Letter of Defect and How Is It Cleared?
Reviewed by a licensed Professional Engineer · NY, NJ, PA, MD, DE · Last reviewed · Code basis: NYC Fire Code (2022) and FDNY rules (3 RCNY) on fire alarm plan examination, inspection and certification of corrected defects; Local Law 195 of 2018; NFPA 72 (2019 as adopted by NYC)
General guidance, not a code determination for any project. Confirm the adopted code and local amendments with the authority having jurisdiction.
An FDNY Letter of Defect, now issued as a Notice of Defect, lists the items a fire alarm system failed at FDNY inspection. It is not the end of the job: most items can be cleared without a second inspection by correcting them and filing an FA-26 Certification of Corrected Defects within 90 days. After 90 days, FDNY has to inspect again.
Owners and contractors often confuse the Letter of Defect with the objections FDNY raises on the plans, and both with the final Letter of Approval. This guide sorts out the letters, shows where the TM-1 application fits, explains how defects are cleared, and lists the items that most often fail.
At a Glance: FDNY Fire Alarm Letters
- Symptom: a Notice of Defect (formerly Letter of Defect) listing the items the installed fire alarm system failed at FDNY inspection, and no Letter of Approval.
- Likely causes: records that do not match the accepted riser (labels, addresses, missing as-builts or central station documents) or field conditions that do not perform (audibility, strobe coverage, battery capacity, elevator recall, fan shutdown or door release sequence).
- How to confirm: sort each listed item into records or field, check it against the accepted TM-1 drawings and the sequence of operations, and retest the field items.
- Fix: correct the items and file the FA-26 Certification of Corrected Defects within 90 days of the notice, or the FA-27 for document-only items; after 90 days FDNY has to inspect again.
- Who to involve: the fire alarm contractor and certificate of fitness holder who retest, the licensed professional who signs the FA-26, and the elevator, mechanical or door hardware trade for any interface item.
- Not to be confused with: plan objections (Letter of Deficiency) at the TM-1 stage, or the Letter of Acceptance for the plans; since June 2019 fire alarm plans are filed with FDNY, not the Department of Buildings.
Four FDNY Letters People Mix Up
A fire alarm job in New York City produces up to four different letters, two at the plan stage and two at the inspection stage. Only one of them is the finish line.
Figure 1: Problem Letters vs Approval Letters
- Letter of Deficiency (objections): the plans need changes before FDNY will accept them
- Notice of Defect (formerly Letter of Defect): the installed system failed items at inspection
- Letter of Acceptance: the plans are accepted, with a stamped TM-1 and stamped drawings
- Letter of Approval: the installed system is approved. This is the one the building needs
Where It Starts: The FDNY TM-1 Application
The TM-1, FDNY’s Application for Plan Examination/Document Review, is the form that carries fire alarm drawings into FDNY plan examination. Since June 2019, under Local Law 195, fire alarm plans in New York City are filed with FDNY rather than the Department of Buildings, through the FDNY Business portal, and the filing is tracked by FDNY.
A complete package reads as one design. FDNY’s examiner expects:
- Device layout plans for every floor in scope, with initiating devices, notification appliances and control functions shown and labeled.
- A riser diagram that matches the plans device for device, with panel and transponder locations.
- A sequence of operations that states what the system does for every initiating event: notification zones, elevator recall, fan shutdown, smoke damper and door release.
- Secondary power (battery) and voltage drop calculations for the notification circuits.
- Equipment data for the listed panels and devices, and the central station arrangement.
When the examiner finds problems, they come back as objections. The resubmission answers each one and includes the latest objection letter; FDNY’s resubmission instructions set the time window and any fee.
Figure 2: What a Complete TM-1 Package Holds
Figure 3: The FDNY Fire Alarm Path
Decoding the FDNY Letter of Defect
When FDNY’s inspector tests the installed system and items fail, each one is listed on the Notice of Defect. The items fall into two groups that are fixed very differently: records that don’t match, and field conditions that don’t perform.
| Typical defect | Group | Usual fix |
|---|---|---|
| Device labels or addresses don’t match the accepted riser | Records | Reprogram labels, correct the drawings, resubmit documents. Often no field work. |
| Missing as-built drawings or central station documentation | Records | Provide the documents. Answered with the FA-27 when nothing in the field changes. |
| Audibility below target in loud rooms | Field | Add or relocate appliances, raise taps, adjust zoning. The usual public mode target is 15 dB above the average ambient sound level. |
| Strobe coverage short after a partition change | Field | Add or relocate strobes and revise the drawings to match the room as built. |
| Batteries short of the standby and alarm period | Field | Recalculate and resize. NFPA 72 asks for 24 hours of standby, then 5 minutes of alarm, or 15 minutes for voice evacuation. |
| Elevator recall, fan shutdown or door release out of sequence | Field | Correct the interface wiring or programming with the affected trade, then retest. |
NFPA 72 values as commonly applied; confirm the edition and any FDNY amendments that govern the job.
Clearing the Defects: FA-26 and the 90-Day Window
FDNY does not require a second inspection for every defect. If the items are corrected and the FA-26 Certification of Corrected Defects is filed within 90 days of the notice, the certification can clear them. The FA-26 is signed by the people the form names, including a licensed professional and the certificate of fitness holder who tested the corrections, and it is filed with the fee and supporting documents FDNY lists on the form. Defects that are documents only are answered with the FA-27. Once FDNY accepts the corrections, it issues the Letter of Approval.
Figure 4: The 90-Day Window
Figure 5: Answering a Notice of Defect
How to Avoid a Notice of Defect
Before Requesting the FDNY Inspection
- Pre-test 100 percent of the devices, and keep the test records ready.
- Walk the installation against the accepted drawings: labels, addresses and zone descriptions should match the riser and the panel.
- Measure sound levels in mechanical rooms, kitchens and open offices with sound masking before FDNY does.
- Run every interface the sequence of operations lists: elevator recall, fans, dampers, door holders.
- Have the as-built drawings and central station documentation on site.
The records items are the cheapest to prevent. A label mismatch caught on a pre-test walk is a reprogramming task; caught by FDNY, it is a Notice of Defect, a certification and a delay to the Letter of Approval the building needs for its certificate of occupancy.
DGA prepares FDNY fire alarm filings, answers objections and clears defects on projects across New York City, and designs fire alarm systems in New York State, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Delaware. Project briefs get confirmation and preliminary code feedback within one business day. See where DGA works →
Key Takeaway: an FDNY Letter of Defect lists inspection items, not plan objections, and most of it can be cleared with an FA-26 certification inside 90 days. Pre-test everything, match the records to the riser, and the Letter of Approval follows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an FDNY Letter of Defect the same as a plan objection?
No. Objections come from plan examination and are answered by revising and resubmitting the drawings. A Letter of Defect, now a Notice of Defect, comes from the inspection of the installed system.
Does every defect need a second FDNY inspection?
No. If the items are corrected and the FA-26 Certification of Corrected Defects is filed within 90 days, the certification can clear them. After 90 days, a re-inspection is required.
How long do I have to correct the defects?
90 days from the date of the notice, to certify the corrections without a re-inspection. Check the date on the notice and plan the retest so the paperwork is in well before the deadline.
What is the FDNY TM-1 application?
FDNY’s Application for Plan Examination/Document Review. It carries fire alarm plans and other fire protection documents into FDNY review and is filed through the FDNY Business portal.
Which letter does the building actually need?
The FDNY Letter of Approval for the installed fire alarm system. It is typically required before the Department of Buildings issues a certificate of occupancy for work that includes a fire alarm.
This article is general information, not a substitute for a project-specific review. FDNY forms, fees and procedures change; confirm the current versions for the job.
Holding a Notice of Defect?
Send the notice and the accepted drawings. DGA reviews each item, plans the corrections and the certification, and works toward the Letter of Approval. Project briefs get confirmation and preliminary code feedback within one business day.