Approvals by Jurisdiction · Jurisdiction
What Does NYC Local Law 5 Still Require of Office Towers?
General guidance, not a code determination for any project. Confirm the adopted code and local amendments with the authority having jurisdiction.
New York City Local Law 5 of 1973 still requires existing office buildings 100 ft or taller to keep the fire safety features it ordered, because Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1 binds prior code buildings to the retroactive requirements of the 1968 Building Code, where Local Law 5 wrote those features. Its fire safety plan and fire safety director rules continue in the 2022 NYC Fire Code as the fire safety and emergency action plan and the Fire and Life Safety Director.
Most Local Law 5 deadlines ran out in the 1970s and 1980s, so the law rarely drives new work. It still matters in three places: Local Law 26 of 2004 measured office towers against it, the Fire Code’s plan rules still reach buildings that once needed a fire safety director, and buyers and lenders ask which compliance path an older tower relies on.
At a Glance: NYC Local Law 5 of 1973
- Jurisdiction: New York City; existing office buildings (Group E under the 1968 Building Code, Group B today) 100 ft or taller, plus office buildings above the occupant thresholds for the fire safety plan.
- Local code and edition: Local Law 5 of 1973, codified in the 1968 Building Code and kept in force for prior code buildings by Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1; fire safety plans under Section FC 404.2.1 of the 2022 NYC Fire Code (as of November 2026).
- Agency (authority having jurisdiction, AHJ): the NYC Department of Buildings (DOB) for the building features; the Fire Department of the City of New York (FDNY) for the fire safety plan, the Fire and Life Safety Director and fire alarm filings.
- Filing or permit name: alteration jobs in DOB NOW: Build for building work; FDNY’s TM-1 plan examination application for fire alarm changes; the fire safety and emergency action plan, filed with FDNY for acceptance.
- Key difference from the model code: the International Building Code (IBC) lets an existing building keep its lawful occupancy unless a code specifically requires an upgrade (IBC Section 102.6); New York City used a local law to order named upgrades in every existing office tower 100 ft or taller, on fixed deadlines.
- Review time range (as of November 2026): the retroactive requirement itself has no review step; DOB must approve compliant construction documents, or reject them with the grounds stated, no later than 40 calendar days after a complete application, extendable once by 20 days for good cause (Administrative Code Sections 28-104.2.7 and 28-104.2.8).
What Did Local Law 5 of 1973 Require?
Local Law 5 amended two parts of the Administrative Code of the time: the fire prevention rules in Chapter 19 and the Building Code sections in Chapter 26 (the 1968 Building Code). The law set two groups of rules with different triggers. The operational rules turned on occupant load, and the hardware rules turned on building height.
The operational rules, in new Section C19-161.2, covered Group E office buildings with more than 100 occupants above or below street level or more than 500 in the building. Those buildings needed a fire safety plan approved by FDNY, a fire safety director and at least one deputy holding certificates of fitness, a fire brigade of building service employees, and regular fire drills.
The hardware rules applied to a defined “existing office building, 100 ft. or more in height”: an office building complete or under construction when the law took effect, or one whose plans were filed close to that date and built soon after. Local Law 5 required compartmentation of unsprinklered floors, a smoke shaft or stair pressurization, stair reentry and signs, a fire alarm with voice communication, a lobby fire command station and Fire Department elevator controls.
Sprinklers were the alternative. A fully sprinklered building was exempt from compartmentation and smoke venting. Most system work was due within 3 years of the effective date, smoke venting within 3.5 years, and compartmentation in thirds over 5, 10 and 15 years, and the commissioner could waive or modify a requirement for practical difficulty or undue hardship.
| Feature | Local Law 5 rule (1973) | Status today (as of November 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Compartmentation | Where the air system serves more than one floor, unsprinklered floor areas more than 40 ft above the curb divided by 1-hour separations into compartments of 7,500 sq ft or less, with a 2-hour refuge separation on floors over 10,000 sq ft (C26-504.1(c)) | A retroactive 1968 code requirement under Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1; it falls away for a fully sprinklered building, which Local Law 26 required by July 1, 2019 |
| Smoke shaft or stair pressurization | At least one smoke shaft or pressurized interior stairs in an unsprinklered building where the air system serves more than one floor (C26-504.15) | Not required in a fully sprinklered building under Local Law 5’s own exemption; a system left in service still has to work as designed |
| Stair reentry and signs | Stair doors openable from the stair side at intervals of no more than 4 stories; floor, stair and reentry signs | Still a retroactive requirement under Section 28-102.4.1 |
| Fire alarm and voice communication | A Class E fire alarm (modified Class E where a system already existed) with loudspeakers on each floor, in stairs and in elevators, and two-way voice to floor warden stations | Still required; changes to fire alarm systems have been filed with FDNY, not DOB, since June 2, 2019 (Local Law 195 of 2018) |
| Fire command station | A fire command station with the communication system in the entrance-floor lobby (C26-1704.8) | Still a retroactive requirement under Section 28-102.4.1 |
| Elevator controls | Fire Department controls, with cars kept available for Fire Department use (C26-1800.8) | Still a retroactive requirement under Section 28-102.4.1 |
| Fire safety plan and director | An FDNY-approved fire safety plan, a fire safety director and deputy, a fire brigade and drills (C19-161.2) | Carried into the 2022 NYC Fire Code: a fire safety and emergency action plan (FC 404.2.1) and a Fire and Life Safety Director on premises during regular business hours (FC 401.4.5.1) |
Local Law 5 vs the Current Code and Local Law 26
Local Law 26 of 2004 did not undo Local Law 5; it added a full sprinkler mandate for existing office buildings 100 ft or taller, due July 1, 2019. DOB Buildings Bulletin 2017-017 explains how the two laws meet. High-rise office buildings erected before Local Law 16 of 1984 that complied with the Local Law 5 sprinkler option (1968 code Section 27-339(c)(5)), with the sprinkler work signed off on or before October 22, 2004, are exempt from the Local Law 26 mandate and its filing requirements.
Pre-1984 office towers that took the compartmentation path instead were caught by Local Law 26 and had to sprinkler fully. High-rise office buildings built after Local Law 16 of 1984 were already required to be sprinklered, so Local Law 26 asked nothing of them. The detail of the Local Law 26 mandate, its reports and its enforcement is covered in DGA’s article on what NYC Local Law 26 required for office sprinklers.
| Point of comparison | Local Law 5 of 1973 | Local Law 26 of 2004 |
|---|---|---|
| Buildings reached | Existing office buildings 100 ft or taller (hardware); office buildings above the occupant thresholds (plan and director) | Office buildings 100 ft or taller in existence on October 22, 2004 without a full sprinkler system |
| Role of sprinklers | An alternative that removed compartmentation and smoke venting | Mandatory full sprinkler protection |
| Other features | Alarm and voice communication, fire command station, elevator controls, stair reentry, fire safety plan and director | Sprinklers are the core of the mandate; see the Local Law 26 article |
| Deadlines | 3 to 15 years from the effective date, by feature | July 1, 2019, with reports at years 1, 7 and 14 |
| Where it sits | 1968 Building Code sections and the former Fire Prevention Code | 1968 code Sections 27-929.1 and 27-228.5 |
| Interaction | Sprinkler option signed off by October 22, 2004 exempts the building from Local Law 26 | Applies to pre-1984 towers that did not take the Local Law 5 sprinkler option |
The model codes have no equivalent of either law. The IBC governs new work, and IBC Section 102.6 lets existing buildings continue in lawful use unless that code, the International Fire Code (IFC), the International Existing Building Code or the property maintenance code specifically requires otherwise. New York City wrote its retrofit mandates as local laws and keeps them alive through its own Administrative Code.
| Issue | Model codes (IBC and IFC) | New York City |
|---|---|---|
| Upgrades to existing office towers | Only where a code specifically requires them (IBC Section 102.6; IFC Chapter 11) | Named retrofits by local law, kept in force by Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1 |
| Fire safety and evacuation planning | IFC Chapter 4 fire safety and evacuation plans | Fire safety and emergency action plan accepted by FDNY (FC 404.2.1, FC 401.4.4) |
| Who runs the plan | Owner’s staff as the plan assigns | A Fire and Life Safety Director holding an FDNY F-89 certificate of fitness (FC 401.4.5.1) |
Which Office Buildings Did Local Law 5 Reach?
Local Law 5 reached office buildings by two measures. The fire safety plan and director rules applied by occupant load, so a shorter office building with more than 500 occupants, or more than 100 above or below street level, was covered. The hardware rules applied only to office buildings 100 ft or taller that existed, were under construction or had plans filed close to the law’s effective date.
Office buildings planned later were designed under the new-building rules of the amended 1968 code, and from 1984 under Local Law 16 as well. That split is why the age of an office tower matters as much as its height. The question for an older tower is which rules applied when it was built and which retrofit path it took.
Figure 1: Local Law 5 Triggers, From Occupant Load to Height
Three facts settle coverage for a given building: its height, whether it was an office building, and when its plans were filed and construction finished. Those facts come from the certificate of occupancy, the original filings and DOB’s records for the building.
Who Enforces Local Law 5 Compliance Today?
DOB enforces the building features. Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1 requires prior code buildings to comply with the retroactive requirements of the 1968 Building Code, including those requiring fire safety and building safety systems, and makes a failure to comply a violation of the current code. Work to restore or change a Local Law 5 feature is filed as an alteration in DOB NOW: Build.
The NYC Existing Building Code does not end that duty. Its own text, enacted as Local Law 33 of 2026, states that the retroactive provisions of the 1968 code remain applicable to existing prior code buildings and enforceable by DOB (Existing Building Code Section 302.8, Exception 2). The NYC Existing Building Code and its July 17, 2027 effective date are covered separately.
FDNY enforces the operational side. Section FC 404.2.1 of the 2022 NYC Fire Code requires a fire safety and emergency action plan for high-rise or large-area Group B office buildings occupied by more than 500 persons, or by more than 100 above or below street level, and for office buildings that were required to have a fire safety director before the section took effect. FC 401.4.4 requires FDNY acceptance of the plan before occupancy, and FC 401.4.5.1 requires a Fire and Life Safety Director holding a certificate of fitness to be present during regular business hours.
FDNY lists that certificate as the F-89 and requires it in buildings that previously needed a fire safety director. The certificates a building’s staff may need are covered in DGA’s guide to which FDNY certificates of fitness a building needs. Fire alarm changes, including work on the voice communication system, are filed with FDNY on the TM-1.
Figure 2: From Local Law 5 to the Existing Building Code
DGA reviews Local Law 5 and Local Law 26 compliance records and prepares code analyses for older office towers in New York City, and works across New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Delaware. Project briefs get confirmation and preliminary code feedback within one business day. See where DGA works →
What Owners and Buyers Still Need to Document for Local Law 5
A Local Law 5 review starts with the compliance path. A tower that took the sprinkler option needs proof that the sprinkler work was signed off on or before October 22, 2004, and Buildings Bulletin 2017-017 has those owners report compliance on its Attachment A. A tower that took the compartmentation path should show its Local Law 26 sprinkler compliance instead.
The other Local Law 5 features need their own records. The list below is what a buyer, lender or new owner should expect to see.
- Height, occupancy and construction date, from the certificate of occupancy and the original filings.
- The sprinkler record: the Attachment A filing and sign-offs for a Local Law 5 option building, or the Local Law 26 compliance record.
- FDNY approval of the fire alarm and voice communication system, including later changes.
- The fire command station and Fire Department elevator controls in service.
- An FDNY-accepted fire safety and emergency action plan, a Fire and Life Safety Director on staff, and drill records.
- Any waiver or modification granted under Local Law 5, in writing.
- A search for open DOB violations and Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH) summonses.
Tenant work is where gaps appear. A fit-out that relocates speakers or floor warden stations changes the voice communication system, and on any floor that is still unsprinklered, removing a rated compartment wall undoes a Local Law 5 compliance item. A wider check of the other retroactive laws is in DGA’s checklist of NYC retroactive fire laws by building type.
Key Takeaway: Local Law 5 of 1973 is not history. Its retrofits live on as retroactive requirements of the 1968 Building Code under Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1, and its fire safety plan and director rules live on in FC 404.2.1 and the F-89 Fire and Life Safety Director. For an older office tower, the documents that matter are the sprinkler sign-off or Local Law 26 record, the FDNY fire alarm approval and the accepted fire safety plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Local Law 5 still in effect?
Yes. Local Law 5 wrote its office building retrofits into the 1968 Building Code, and Administrative Code Section 28-102.4.1 requires prior code buildings to comply with the retroactive requirements of that code. Its fire safety plan and director rules continue in the 2022 NYC Fire Code (FC 404.2.1 and FC 401.4.5.1).
Did Local Law 26 replace Local Law 5?
No. Local Law 26 of 2004 added a full sprinkler mandate for existing office buildings 100 ft or taller, due July 1, 2019. Buildings that completed the Local Law 5 sprinkler option, with the work signed off by October 22, 2004, are exempt from that mandate under Buildings Bulletin 2017-017, and the other Local Law 5 features still apply.
What is a Local Law 5 fire safety plan?
The fire safety plan Local Law 5 required of office buildings with more than 100 occupants above or below street level, or more than 500 in the building, run by a certified fire safety director. Today the 2022 NYC Fire Code requires a fire safety and emergency action plan accepted by FDNY (FC 404.2.1), run by a Fire and Life Safety Director holding an F-89 certificate of fitness.
How does Local Law 5 affect due diligence?
It adds a records check on older office towers: which compliance path the building took, the sprinkler sign-off or Local Law 26 record, FDNY approval of the fire alarm and voice communication system, the accepted fire safety plan, and any open DOB violations.
More in Approvals by Jurisdiction
- How Does AHJ Review Work in NYC, NJ and Philadelphia?
- How Do Pittsburgh Fire Protection Approvals Work?
- How Do Federal Agencies Review Leased-Space Fire Protection?
- What Is Maryland’s Sprinkler Law for New Homes?
- Does the Pennsylvania Fire and Panic Act Still Apply?
- What Does NYC Require for Construction Site Fire Safety?
This article is general information, not a code determination for any building. Code text, DOB records and FDNY practice change; confirm coverage, exemptions and current records with the authority having jurisdiction.
Reviewing an Older Office Tower?
Send the address, the year built and the records on hand. DGA identifies the Local Law 5 and Local Law 26 compliance path, checks the sprinkler, fire alarm and fire safety plan records and flags the gaps before a deal or an alteration. Project briefs get confirmation and preliminary code feedback within one business day.