Storage and Commodities · Comparison

ESFR or In-Rack Sprinklers: Which Protects Rack Storage?

Reviewed by a licensed Professional Engineer · NY, NJ, PA, MD, DE · Last reviewed · Code basis: NFPA 13 Ch. 23 and 25 (2022; 2019 PA and MD; 2016 NYC App. Q; 2025 DE); FM DS 8-9

General guidance, not a code determination for any project. Confirm the adopted code and local amendments with the authority having jurisdiction.

ESFR sprinklers protect rack storage from the ceiling alone, and in-rack sprinklers protect it from inside the rack, so the choice comes down to whether the building, the commodity and the water supply fit inside the ceiling-only limits of National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 13 Chapter 23. When they do, ESFR (early suppression, fast response) sprinklers keep the racks clear of piping and let the tenant rearrange storage without touching the sprinkler system. When they do not, in-rack sprinklers under NFPA 13 Chapter 25 put water where the fire starts and work with a ceiling system that can be far less demanding.

Neither option is the default. Most distribution buildings in New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Delaware end up with ESFR because their roofs are flat, their ceilings are clear and their commodities are cartoned, but cold storage, mixed plastics, solid shelves and very tall racks push projects toward in-rack protection. This article compares the two on scope, design basis, limits and operating consequences, then lays out how a design team chooses. The question of when in-rack sprinklers become mandatory has its own article, linked below.

At a Glance: ESFR vs In-Rack Sprinklers

  • Option A, ESFR: ceiling-only suppression with fast-response K-14 to K-25.2 (and larger) sprinklers on a wet pipe system, typically 12 heads in the design, no sprinklers in the racks. NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 23, with the installation rules in Chapter 14.
  • Option B, in-rack: sprinklers mounted on levels inside the rack, in the flue spaces and at the faces, matched with a ceiling system whose density Chapter 25 sets for that in-rack scheme. NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 25.
  • Deciding factor: whether the ceiling height, storage height, commodity, rack construction and system type all sit inside the Chapter 23 ceiling-only tables and listings. One miss sends the project to in-rack protection or a different ceiling scheme.
  • When ESFR applies: ceilings up to 45 ft, Class I to IV and cartoned plastics in open-frame racks, a heated building, a wet system, roof slope of 2 in 12 or less and a supply or pump that carries the design.
  • When in-rack applies: storage or ceilings above the ceiling-only limits, exposed expanded plastics and other commodities outside the ESFR listings, solid shelves, open-top containers and water supplies that cannot carry 12 large heads.
  • Cost and complexity direction: ESFR costs more in water supply and less in rack piping; in-rack costs more in piping, rack coordination and every future rack change, and often less in pump and supply. As of October 2026, the water supply usually decides which direction is cheaper.

ESFR and In-Rack Sprinklers Side by Side

The two strategies differ in where the water comes from, what the design assumes about the fire and how much of the building has to cooperate. The table compares them on the points that decide a design. Heights are the ceiling-only limits of the 2022 edition; the jurisdiction table further down lists which edition each state enforces.

ESFR (ceiling only)In-rack sprinklers
ScopeRack, palletized and solid-piled storage of Class I to IV commodities and cartoned Group A plastics, plus limited exposed plastics, within the Chapter 23 tables and the sprinkler listingRack storage of any class, at any height, in the schemes Chapter 25 lays out, including commodities and arrangements that ceiling-only protection does not cover
Design basisSuppression: a fixed number of sprinklers (12 in most cases) at a minimum pressure set by K-factor and ceiling height, Chapter 23Control: a fixed number of in-rack sprinklers operating at once, plus a ceiling density over a design area that Chapter 25 pairs with the scheme
Ceiling heightUp to 45 ft for ceiling-only protection; the largest K-factors are needed at the top of that rangeNo ceiling-only ceiling limit; the in-rack levels protect the storage and the ceiling system protects the building
Storage heightNot a separate index: the 2022 ESFR table is set by maximum ceiling height, and K-14 and K-16.8 stop at lower ceilings than K-22.4 and K-25.2 (see the ceiling-only height article)Set by the number and spacing of in-rack levels, with the top level below the top of storage or a horizontal barrier above it
CommoditiesClass I to IV, cartoned unexpanded and cartoned expanded plastics, exposed unexpanded plastics within listed limits, and exposed expanded plastics only through the K-25.2 route (storage to 35 ft, ceiling to 40 ft)All of the above plus exposed expanded plastics beyond the ESFR limits, mixed commodities and arrangements the ESFR tables exclude
Rack typeOpen-frame single, double and multiple-row racks with the flue spaces Chapter 20 requires; solid shelves only within the area limitOpen-frame racks, racks with solid shelves (sprinklers at the shelf levels Chapter 20 sets), and racks with horizontal barriers
System typeWet pipe, unless the sprinkler is specifically listed for dry or preaction use (Chapter 14)Wet pipe in heated areas; the 25.6 in-rack options are wet pipe only, and 25.4.3.3 addresses CMSA ceilings with preaction
Water demand directionHigh flow at high pressure at the ceiling: 12 K-16.8 heads at 52 psi draw about 1,450 gpm before hoseLower ceiling demand, plus the in-rack sprinklers Chapter 25 assumes operating; total demand often lower, with less dependence on a fire pump
Effect of rack changesRacks move freely as long as heights, flue spaces and commodities stay within the designEvery rack relocation, tier change or shelf change moves piping and needs a new permit and shop drawings
Cost and complexity directionMore in supply and pump, less in piping and coordination; fastest to install in an empty shellMore in piping, hangers, rack coordination and impact protection; less in pump; slower to install and to change

Chapter numbers follow NFPA 13 (2022). The 2019 edition enforced in Pennsylvania and Maryland uses the same chapter layout (ESFR in Chapter 23, in-rack in Chapter 25) with different table values; the 2016 edition used in New York City organizes storage by arrangement and commodity in Chapters 12 to 20.

Figure 1: Two Ways to Reach the Fire

ESFR: suppress from the ceiling
  • K-14 to K-25.2 fast-response sprinklers at the ceiling only
  • 12 sprinklers in the design at a listed pressure
  • Ceiling to 45 ft, Class I to IV and cartoned plastics
  • Wet pipe, roof slope 2 in 12 or less, clear of obstructions
  • Racks can be rearranged without a sprinkler permit
In-rack: control inside the rack
  • Sprinklers on rack levels in flue spaces and at rack faces
  • In-rack sprinklers plus a paired ceiling density
  • Any height, any commodity class, solid shelves and barriers
  • Mostly wet pipe; dry or preaction only where Chapter 25 allows
  • Every rack change becomes a sprinkler change
ESFR under NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 23 protects rack storage under ceilings to 45 ft from the ceiling alone with 12 K-14 to K-25.2 sprinklers on a wet system; in-rack sprinklers under Chapter 25 protect any height and commodity with operating in-rack heads paired with a ceiling density, at the cost of piping that moves whenever the racks move.

How ESFR Protects Rack Storage

An ESFR sprinkler opens fast and discharges a large volume at high momentum, enough to push water down through the fire plume to the burning carton before the fire spreads beyond a handful of heads. NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 23 lists the ceiling-only designs by ceiling height, K-factor and commodity, and the 2022 table (23.3.1) is indexed by maximum ceiling height alone, not by pairs of storage and ceiling height. The design is a fixed count of sprinklers, usually 12, at the pressure the table gives for the K-factor and ceiling.

The strategy only works if nothing gets between the sprinkler and the fire. Chapter 14 sets the obstruction rules for ESFR sprinklers and limits the roof slope to 2 in 12, and the flue space requirements in Chapter 20 keep a vertical path open through the rack. ESFR sprinklers are installed on wet pipe systems unless the sprinkler is specifically listed for dry or preaction use (Chapter 14), because the delay of a dry system defeats the early suppression the design relies on. The other ceiling-only choices are control mode specific application (CMSA) sprinklers in Chapter 22 and control mode density area (CMDA) sprinklers in Chapter 21; DGA’s comparison of ESFR and CMSA sprinklers for a warehouse covers that choice and the 12-head hydraulic demand in more detail.

How In-Rack Sprinklers Protect Rack Storage

In-rack sprinklers sit on branch lines inside the rack, at the intersections of the transverse and longitudinal flue spaces and, in some schemes, at the rack face. Because they are close to the fuel, they operate early and wet the commodity directly, so the design goal is control rather than suppression. NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 25 gathers the in-rack schemes that earlier editions spread across the commodity chapters, and pairs each scheme with the ceiling density that goes with it.

Chapter 25 offers several arrangements. The traditional schemes place one level of in-rack sprinklers for a stated vertical interval of storage, with the interval tighter for plastics than for Class I to IV commodities, and set the ceiling density to match. The horizontal barrier schemes add a solid barrier of sheet metal or plywood at set heights with in-rack sprinklers beneath it, which contains the fire to one zone of the rack. A third option puts sprinklers at every tier level, and the Chapter 25 tables pair it with a 0.15 gpm per sq ft ceiling density instead of a full storage density.

The hydraulic demand is the in-rack sprinklers assumed to operate at once, balanced with the ceiling demand at the point of connection (2022 25.1.10.5), plus the hose stream. In-rack sprinklers need water shields where they are not under barriers (2022 25.1.6.4), a 6 in nominal transverse flue so the branch lines and the water path stay open, and rack drawings that match the sprinkler drawings exactly. The article on when NFPA 13 requires in-rack sprinklers covers the thresholds that make them mandatory.

Figure 2: Where Each Sprinkler Sits in a Rack Section

Roof deck, 45 ft ceiling, slope 2 in 12 or less Floor ESFR, K-22.4 or K-25.2, 12 in the design Ceiling sprinklers paired with in-rack levels Open-frame double-row rack, ESFR only Same rack with in-rack sprinklers 6 in flue Horizontal barrier In-rack level 2 In-rack level 1 Aisle
Under NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 23, ESFR K-22.4 or K-25.2 sprinklers at a 45 ft ceiling protect open-frame racks with nothing in the rack but the 6 in flue spaces Chapter 20 requires. Under Chapter 25, in-rack sprinklers sit on levels in the longitudinal flue and at the rack face, with a horizontal barrier where the scheme calls for one, and the ceiling system is designed to the density Chapter 25 pairs with that scheme.

Opens the Project Desk with your sentence. Our licensed PEs review every brief and reply within one business day.

How to Choose Between ESFR and In-Rack Sprinklers

The choice is a sequence of checks, and the order matters because the first failed check usually settles it. A design team runs the building through the seven criteria below before anyone draws a branch line.

CriterionFavors ESFRFavors in-rack
Ceiling height45 ft or less, measured to the deck or the lowest obstruction that acts as a ceilingAbove 45 ft, or a ceiling that steps, slopes past 2 in 12 or is crowded with structure and equipment
Storage heightWithin the Chapter 23 limit for the chosen K-factor, with the ceiling clearance the table assumesAbove the ceiling-only limit, or storage that the tenant intends to push higher later
Commodity classClass I to IV and cartoned plastics, confirmed by a commodity surveyExposed expanded plastics beyond the K-25.2 limits, mixed or unknown commodities, aerosols, flammable liquids and other items outside the ESFR tables
Rack type and flexibilityOpen-frame racks with flue spaces that the operator will keep; wire mesh or slatted shelves within the open area limitsSolid shelves, pick modules, multi-level mezzanines inside racks
Tenant turnoverSpeculative or multi-tenant buildings where the next occupant’s racks are unknownOwner-occupied facilities with a fixed rack plan that will not move for years
Water supplyA supply, or a fire pump, that can deliver 12 large heads at the listed pressure plus hoseA weak supply, a site that cannot fit a pump or tank, or a budget that cannot carry them
Future growthGrowth by adding racks of the same height and commodityGrowth by going higher, adding automation or changing the product mix

Two of these criteria carry more weight than the rest. Commodity class decides whether the ESFR tables apply at all, which is why a commodity survey of what the tenant stores, how it is packaged and what the pallets are made of comes first. Water supply decides whether an ESFR design that fits on paper can be built, so a current hydrant flow test belongs in the same first week.

Figure 3: A First Pass at ESFR or In-Rack

Commodity class, storage height, ceiling height and rack type known
Ceiling 45 ft or less, storage within the Chapter 23 limit for a listed K-factor, commodity in the ESFR tables, open-frame racks, heated building?
No, on any oneIn-rack sprinklers, or a different ceiling schemeChapter 25 schemes; horizontal barriers; CMSA or CMDA with in-rack levels
Yes, on all
Supply carries 12 heads plus hoseESFR candidateConfirm the listing, Chapter 14 obstructions and the 2 in 12 slope limit
Supply falls shortAdd a pump or tank, or go in-rackCompare the pump and tank cost with the piping and flexibility cost
ESFR is only a candidate when the ceiling is 45 ft or less, the storage is within the NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 23 limit for a listed K-factor, the commodity is in the ESFR tables, the racks are open-frame and the building is heated; a miss on any one sends the project to a Chapter 25 in-rack scheme or another ceiling design, and a pass sends it to the water supply, which decides between ESFR and a pump, a tank or in-rack sprinklers.

Where ESFR Is Not Permitted

ESFR fails by exclusion. NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 23 does not offer a ceiling-only design for exposed expanded Group A plastics beyond the limited heights its table lists, so a rack of uncartoned foam products outside those limits has to be protected another way. ESFR is not permitted for open-top containers (2022 23.1.3.2), because a bin that fills with water on an upper tier shields the fire below it; DGA explains the mechanism in why open-top bins defeat rack sprinklers. ESFR may not protect solid shelf racks unless in-rack sprinklers are added per Chapter 25 (2022 23.1.3.1).

The building can disqualify ESFR as well. A roof steeper than 2 in 12 is outside the ESFR slope limit in Chapter 14, and the 2025 edition adopted in Delaware adds deflector rules for roofs over 2 in 12 up to 4 in 12. A dry pipe or preaction system cannot carry ESFR sprinklers unless the sprinkler is specifically listed for that use, which rules out most unheated warehouses and freezers unless the owner heats the space. A ceiling crowded with ducts, conveyors, lights or bar joists that violate the Chapter 14 obstruction rules either gets additional sprinklers below the obstructions or loses the ESFR option.

Where In-Rack Sprinklers Are Not Permitted

In-rack sprinklers are never a stand-alone answer. Every Chapter 25 scheme assumes a ceiling system designed to the density and area that chapter pairs with it; in-rack levels under a ceiling system designed for a lighter hazard do not meet the standard, and a reviewer will reject the hydraulic calculation. The same applies to a building that adds in-rack sprinklers to an existing ESFR system in the hope of covering a commodity the ESFR table excludes, because the combination has to be one the standard or the listing recognizes.

The schemes also carry their own limits. Some in-rack arrangements are listed for specific pallet types, and a change from wood to plastic pallets can move the commodity up a class and out of the scheme. Flue space width and the maximum vertical interval between levels are conditions, not suggestions. In-rack sprinklers in an unheated area need a dry or preaction system that Chapter 25 allows for that scheme, which is not every scheme (the 25.6 options are wet pipe only).

How FM Global Data Sheet 8-9 Changes the Comparison

An FM Global insured site designs to FM Data Sheet 8-9, Storage of Class 1, 2, 3, 4 and Plastic Commodities, alongside NFPA 13, and the two documents do not always agree. FM uses its own commodity classes and its own tables of ceiling-only designs, which often allow larger storage heights for the larger K-factors and set different sprinkler counts and pressures. FM also recognizes in-rack arrangements and horizontal barrier schemes that differ from Chapter 25, and it treats some roof slopes and obstructions more strictly. The practical rule for an FM-insured warehouse is to design to whichever document is stricter for each criterion and to get FM’s review before the permit set is sealed.

Which NFPA 13 Edition Applies in Each State

The comparison above holds across the region. What changes is the edition, and with it the chapter numbers and some of the table values. The 2022 and 2025 editions organize storage protection by sprinkler type (CMDA in Chapter 21, CMSA in Chapter 22, ESFR in Chapter 23, in-rack in Chapter 25). The 2019 edition introduced that layout, so its chapter numbers match, and the 2016 edition that New York City still enforces organizes storage by arrangement and commodity in Chapters 12 to 20.

JurisdictionAdopting codeNFPA 13 editionAuthority having jurisdiction (AHJ)Filing or permit
New York State (outside NYC)2025 Uniform Code (2024 I-Codes)2022Local code enforcement officialBuilding permit with sprinkler and high-piled storage plans
New York City2022 Building Code, Appendix Q2016 (NYC modifications)Department of Buildings (DOB); Fire Department (FDNY) for storage permitsDOB NOW sprinkler work type; FDNY high-piled storage permit
New JerseyUniform Construction Code, 2024 I-Codes (effective August 17, 2026)2022Municipal fire protection subcode officialFire protection subcode permit
PennsylvaniaUniform Construction Code, 2021 I-Codes (January 1, 2026)2019Municipal or third-party code official; Philadelphia Department of Licenses and Inspections (L&I)Building permit with fire suppression plans
Maryland2021 International Building Code (IBC); NFPA 1 (2024)2019County building official; State or local fire marshalBuilding permit with fire marshal plan review
DelawareRegulation 701 (2026)2025Office of the State Fire MarshalFire marshal plan review before the building permit

Editions as of October 2026. Local amendments are not shown; confirm the adopted edition with the AHJ before design.

What the Choice Costs and How Long It Takes

As of October 2026, the cost difference between the two strategies is driven by three items: the fire pump and tank that ESFR usually needs, the in-rack branch lines and their protection that in-rack usually needs, and the cost of every future rack change under an in-rack design. In a shell building with a strong municipal supply, ESFR is usually cheaper to install and far cheaper to live with. Where a pump, a tank and a larger service are needed, the supply work alone can exceed the piping difference, and in-rack protection with a lighter ceiling design can come out ahead.

Schedule follows the same split. ESFR piping goes in before the racks arrive and does not wait for the rack vendor. In-rack piping cannot be designed until the rack drawings are final, and it cannot be installed until the racks stand, so the sprinkler contractor and the rack installer have to work in sequence. Owners in the industrial and high-hazard sector who plan to change their rack layout within a few years should weigh that sequence as a recurring cost, not a one-time one.

Key Takeaway: ESFR protects rack storage from the ceiling alone when the ceiling is 45 ft or less, the storage is within the Chapter 23 limit for the K-factor, the commodity is in the ESFR tables, the racks are open-frame, the system is wet and the supply carries 12 large heads. In-rack sprinklers under Chapter 25 cover everything ESFR cannot, at the price of piping inside the racks and a sprinkler change with every rack change. Classify the commodity and test the water supply first; those two facts usually make the decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can ESFR sprinklers replace in-rack sprinklers?

Yes, when the ceiling is 45 ft or less, the storage is within the NFPA 13 Chapter 23 limit for the chosen K-factor, the commodity is one the ESFR tables cover, the racks are open-frame with the required flue spaces and the system is wet pipe. Outside those limits, ESFR is not a listed option and in-rack sprinklers or another ceiling scheme are required.

Can in-rack sprinklers be used without ceiling sprinklers?

No. Every in-rack scheme in NFPA 13 Chapter 25 pairs the in-rack levels with a ceiling system designed to a stated density and area. The every-tier scheme pairs the in-rack levels with a lower ceiling density (0.15 gpm per sq ft in the 2022 tables), but it still requires ceiling sprinklers.

Which costs more, ESFR or in-rack sprinklers?

Conditional: ESFR costs more in water supply and fire pump, in-rack costs more in piping, rack coordination and future changes. As of October 2026, a shell building with a strong municipal supply usually favors ESFR, and a site that needs a pump and tank often favors in-rack protection with a lighter ceiling design.

Can ESFR sprinklers go on a dry pipe system in a freezer?

Generally no. NFPA 13 requires ESFR sprinklers on wet pipe systems unless the sprinkler is specifically listed for dry or preaction use, because a dry system’s delay defeats early suppression. Freezers and unheated warehouses usually take a CMSA or CMDA dry or preaction design, with in-rack sprinklers only where Chapter 25 addresses that system type.

Does changing the racks require a new sprinkler permit?

Conditional: under an ESFR design, racks can be moved without a sprinkler permit as long as storage height, flue spaces and commodity stay within the design. Under an in-rack design, any change that moves a rack, a tier or a shelf moves piping and requires new shop drawings and a permit.

This article is general information, not a substitute for a project-specific design. Code editions, local amendments, sprinkler listings and insurer requirements change; confirm the adopted NFPA 13 edition and the authority having jurisdiction for the project.

Deciding Between ESFR and In-Rack Sprinklers?

Send the rack layout, the commodity list, the ceiling height and a recent flow test. DGA runs the building through the ceiling-only limits, compares the ESFR and in-rack options and designs the one that fits the supply and the operation. Project briefs get confirmation and preliminary code feedback within one business day.

Send a Project Brief → View Related Services

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Quick inquiry

Ready when you are.

Your name, a way to reach you, and where the project is. One of our licensed PEs replies within one business day. Every inquiry is confidential.

Prefer to describe it first? Open the Project Desk