Licensed PEs in NY · NJ · PA · MD · DE · WA · OR · FLMon to Fri, 9am to 5pm ET · (646) 355-8274 · info@dgaconsulting.net · Project Desk

Sprinkler Systems · Troubleshooting

Why were my sprinkler drawings rejected?

General guidance, not a code determination for any project. Confirm the adopted code and local amendments with the authority having jurisdiction.

Sprinkler drawings are rejected when the plan reviewer cannot confirm from the submittal that the system meets the adopted building code, fire code and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) sprinkler standard. The usual reasons are water supply data that is missing or out of date, a hazard classification or storage basis that is not stated, hydraulic calculations that do not match the layout, and missing documents: the owner’s certificate, product data, a required seal or the installing contractor’s license data.

A rejection is not a verdict on the system. It is the reviewer’s list of what the set did not show, and it closes when the drawings are revised, the calculations are re-run wherever the layout changed, each comment is answered by number and the set is resubmitted under the jurisdiction’s re-review rule. The sections below cover the causes, how to tell them apart, the response, the clocks in each state DGA works in and how to prevent a repeat.

At a Glance: Rejected Sprinkler Drawings

  • What the notice or finding means: the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ) could not verify compliance from the working plans, hydraulic calculations or supporting documents and has listed each open item in writing. The sprinkler permit cannot issue until every item is closed.
  • Top 3 causes: water supply data that is missing or older than the reviewer accepts (NFPA 13 (2022) Section 4.5.1.1 sets 12 months unless the AHJ approves otherwise); a hazard classification or storage basis that is not stated (NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 4); hydraulic calculations that do not match the drawings (NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 28).
  • Response deadline (cited): no code sets one. The limits that run are administrative: in New York City an application is abandoned 12 months after submission unless it is diligently pursued after a rejection, and one found incomplete may be deemed abandoned 90 days after notice (New York City Administrative Code Section 28-104.2.3); where the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry (L&I) reviews, a submission is returned if missing information is not supplied within 10 calendar days.
  • Who can fix it: the engineer or designer who signed the set (design, calculation and seal items); the sprinkler contractor (product data and license data); the owner (owner’s certificate and storage data); the water purveyor (flow test); the architect (ceiling, rating and occupancy information the layout relies on).
  • Time to resolve: as of November 2026, the New York City Department of Buildings (DOB) must act on a resubmission within 20 calendar days (Administrative Code 28-104.2.9) and a New Jersey construction official within 7 business days (New Jersey Administrative Code (N.J.A.C.) 5:23-2.16(a)); the Baltimore City Fire Department publishes 5 to 10 business days. Pennsylvania, New York State and Delaware set no resubmission clock. DGA’s Fire Protection Project Timeline Estimator gives a range for a specific project.
  • What happens if ignored: the drawings stay unapproved, the sprinkler permit does not issue and installation cannot start (in New York City, Administrative Code 28-104.1); an unanswered New York City application is abandoned 12 months after submission unless it is pursued after the rejection.

What does a sprinkler plan review rejection mean?

A sprinkler plan review rejection is a written notice that the working plans, hydraulic calculations or supporting documents do not yet show compliance with the adopted codes and the NFPA standard. The notice lists each item the reviewer could not verify, usually by sheet and comment number. A rejection is a finding about the submittal, not a ruling that the system cannot be approved, and the sprinkler work cannot be permitted or installed until every item is closed.

Each jurisdiction names the notice in its own way. DOB issues a Notice of Objections on the sprinkler (SP) filing in DOB NOW: Build, addressed to the applicant of record and the owner, after a full plan examination or an audit of a professionally certified filing. In New Jersey the fire protection subcode official reviews the plans and the construction official grants or denies the permit, and in Pennsylvania a denial must be in writing, identify the elements that do not comply and cite the Uniform Construction Code (UCC) provisions involved (34 Pa. Code 403.43(a)).

The same kind of comment set comes from third-party and peer reviewers. Prince George’s County, Maryland, has fire protection shop drawings reviewed through its Third-Party Plan Review Program, where the deficiency report carries a column the designer marks as each correction is made and the reviewer’s approval certification letter becomes the plan approval. A peer review that an owner, insurer or lender commissions outside such a program reports to that client, but its comments are answered the same way.

How a submittal moves from filing to permit is covered in DGA’s article on how a sprinkler plan review and approval works. This article picks up where that one ends: the comment letter has arrived.

What are the most common reasons sprinkler drawings are rejected?

Sprinkler rejections fall into three groups: the design basis is missing or stale, the drawings and calculations disagree or leave out required detail, or a document, signature or license the jurisdiction requires is missing. The table lists 12 causes, how to recognize each one in the comment and the set, and the fix.

CauseHow to tellFix
Flow test missing or too oldThe comment cites the water supply data. The test was run more than 12 months before working plan submittal, the limit in each NFPA 13 edition the region uses (Section 4.5.1.1 in 2022 and 2025, 4.6.1.1 in 2019, 23.2.1.1 in 2016) unless the AHJ approves otherwise, or it is older than a local limit such as the 12 months on the Delaware State Fire Marshal’s Preliminary Sprinkler Form.Get a new test, or the AHJ’s written acceptance of the older one where the AHJ allows it, and re-plot the supply before resubmitting.
Hazard, storage or omitted areas not statedThe plans show sprinklers and pipe but no occupancy hazard class for each area (NFPA 13 (2022) Section 4.3), no commodity class or storage height for storage areas, or no reason an area has no sprinklers. Delaware’s form asks for the hazard marked on a floor plan and, where no note is given, assumes the minimum design area for each class.Mark the hazard class and design criteria on every floor plan, add the storage data from the owner, and cite the section that allows each omitted area.
Calculations that do not match the drawingsPipe sizes, lengths, node numbers, K-factors or the design area on the calculation sheets differ from the plans, or the calculation was run on an earlier layout.Re-run the calculation from the final layout, key every node to the plan, and reissue the calculation and the drawings together.
Pipe sizes, hangers or riser details missingPipe runs lack sizes or lengths, hanger types and locations are not shown, or the riser diagram leaves out valves, drains and test connections. NFPA 13 (2022) Section 28.1.3 lists what working plans must show.Add the sizes, lengths, hanger details and a complete riser diagram, and cloud each addition.
Owner’s certificate missingNo signed owner’s certificate is in the submittal, so the hazard and storage basis rests on the designer’s assumptions. NFPA 13 (2022) Section 4.2 has the owner put the building’s intended use, the stored materials and their storage height in writing.Have the owner complete and sign the certificate. Delaware’s Preliminary Sprinkler Form also carries the owner’s signature.
Hydraulic design information sign not detailedThe comment asks for the sign, or the data on the sign detail does not match the final calculation. NFPA 13 (2022) Section 29.4 requires the sign, which includes the installing contractor’s name, and New Jersey requires a weatherproof sign at the alarm valve with the design data set out on Department of Community Affairs (DCA) form F380 (N.J.A.C. 5:23-3.5(d)).Add the sign detail with the data from the final calculation.
Seal, signature or license data missingThe comment cites the jurisdiction’s preparer rule: a professional engineer (PE) or registered architect (RA) seal in New York State (Title 19 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR), Section 1203.3(a)(3)) and on each plan sheet in New Jersey (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.15(f)); in Maryland, the contractor’s license number plus either the National Institute for Certification in Engineering Technologies (NICET) level and certification number of its designated qualified individual or a Maryland PE’s seal (Code of Maryland Regulations (COMAR) 29.06.05.04L); in Delaware, the licensed company’s State Fire Marshal license and certificate holder data on the plans and the calculation cover.Add the missing seal, signature or license block to every sheet and the calculation cover, and reissue.
Product data missingThe comment asks for data sheets for sprinklers, pipe, fittings, valves, hangers or the backflow preventer, or a listing limit cannot be checked. In New York City, Building Code Appendix Q allows nonmetallic pipe such as chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC) only in Group R occupancies 6 stories or less in height.Submit the manufacturer data sheet for each component with the model used marked, matching the K-factors and temperature ratings in the calculation.
Fire department connection or backflow details missingThe fire department connection (FDC) location, size or piping to the system is not shown (International Fire Code (IFC) Section 912), or the backflow preventer and its pressure loss are missing from the riser detail and the calculation. In Delaware the fire department’s chief officer sets the FDC location in writing (Regulation 702, Chapter 4, Section 1.3).Show the FDC location agreed with the fire department and the backflow assembly, and carry the backflow loss into the calculation.
Seismic bracing missing where requiredThe site needs seismic protection under International Building Code (IBC) Section 1613 and the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 7 standard, but the plans show no sway braces or flexible couplings. NFPA 13 (2022) Chapter 18 holds the sprinkler seismic provisions.Add brace locations, brace calculations and details, or state on the plans why the site needs no seismic protection.
Edition or local rule missedNotes or calculations cite an NFPA 13 edition the jurisdiction does not use, or miss a local rule. New York City applies the 2016 edition as modified by Building Code Appendix Q, which deletes the NFPA 13 hose stream allowances, and its Building Code Section 903.1.2 asks for a Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) statement of the minimum pressure in the main for street pressure-fed systems and fire pumps.Check the general notes, the design basis and the calculation against the edition in the jurisdiction table below and its local amendments.
Safety margin below the AHJ’s figureThe demand sits closer to the supply curve than the reviewer accepts. NFPA 13 sets no margin, but Delaware requires 10 pounds per square inch (psi) above the demand (Regulation 702, Chapter 4, Section 1.3.1.5) and Montgomery County, Maryland, asks for 20 percent on NFPA 13 systems.Re-plot with the required margin and, where the design falls short, enlarge pipe or revise the layout before resubmitting.

Flow test comments carry their own causes, from a test taken on the wrong main to a residual drop too small to project. DGA’s article on why an AHJ rejects a hydrant flow test works through them, and its guide to what a sealed set of sprinkler shop drawings includes covers the sheets and calculations a complete submittal carries.

How can a design team tell a missing-information comment from a design error?

Every sprinkler plan review comment falls into one of four types, and the type sets the fix. A missing-information comment asks for an item the code requires in the submittal that the set does not show, and adding the item closes the comment without changing the design. A design error comment finds that the design misses a requirement, such as sprinkler spacing, an obstruction rule, the design density or the safety margin, and needs revised sheets and a re-run calculation.

A clarification comment asks for the basis of a decision, such as why a room is classed as light hazard or why a concealed space has no sprinklers. A clarification can usually be answered in the response letter with the section relied on, with a note added where the answer belongs on the drawings. A local policy comment applies an AHJ rule beyond the NFPA standard, such as Delaware’s 10 psi margin or New York City’s DEP pressure statement, and is met as the AHJ writes it or raised with the reviewer in writing.

Figure 1: Which kind of comment is it?

A plan review comment on the sprinkler working plans, hydraulic calculations or supporting documents
Does the comment ask for an item the submittal does not show, such as a flow test, a hazard note, a detail, a data sheet, a seal or a signature?
YesMissing informationAdd the item, cloud it and point to the sheet; the design does not change
NoThe item is shownGo to the design question
Does the comment find that the design misses a requirement, such as spacing, an obstruction, the density, a pipe size or the margin?
YesDesign errorRevise the layout, re-run the calculation from the final layout and reissue the signed or sealed sheets
NoThe design is not disputedGo to the basis question
Does the comment ask why, or for the section relied on, without naming a requirement the design misses?
YesClarificationAnswer in the response letter with the section relied on, and add a note where the answer belongs on the drawings
NoLocal policyAn AHJ rule beyond the NFPA standard: meet it as written, or raise it with the reviewer in writing
Only a design error comment changes the design. Missing-information and clarification comments close with an added item or a written answer, and a local policy comment is met as the AHJ writes it, such as the 10 psi margin above the demand that Delaware’s Regulation 702, Chapter 4, Section 1.3.1.5 requires.

Opens the Project Desk with your sentence. Our licensed PEs review every brief and reply within one business day.

How should the response to sprinkler comments be built, step by step?

A response meant to close in one cycle is built from the comment letter outward, and on a sprinkler submittal most changes ripple into the calculation. The steps run in this order so that the calculation is re-run once, on the final layout.

  1. Number, sort and assign every comment. Copy each comment into a response matrix with its number, the sheet it concerns and its type from the decision tree, then assign it: design and calculation items to the engineer or designer, data sheets and license data to the contractor, the certificate and storage data to the owner, and a new flow test to the water purveyor.
  2. Request the outside items first. A new flow test, a signed owner’s certificate and missing data sheets come from other parties, so the requests go out on the first day while the design items are worked.
  3. Revise the layout, then re-run the calculation. Make every drawing change before re-running the hydraulic calculation so that the calculation reflects the final layout, then bring the riser diagram and the hydraulic design information sign detail into line with the new results.
  4. Re-check the supply and the margin. Plot the revised demand, with the hose allowance where the jurisdiction applies one, against a current supply curve, and confirm the margin the AHJ expects.
  5. Cloud, number and sign the revised sheets. Mark every change with a revision cloud and number, reissue the full calculation rather than single pages, and seal or sign the sheets as the jurisdiction’s preparer rule requires.
  6. Answer every comment in writing. For each comment, state what changed and on which sheet or calculation page, or give the section relied on where nothing changed. A reply of “revised” alone leaves the reviewer to search the set.
  7. Resubmit in the agency’s format. New York City objections are resolved by electronic submission or an appointment with DOB plan examination staff. Montgomery County’s Department of Permitting Services (DPS) takes corrected sheets in the original folder under the original file names and keeps its REVISIONS folder for changes after the permit issues, and Prince George’s third-party reviewers expect the correction column completed before they re-review.

Figure 2: From comment letter to re-review

Comment letterThe reviewer issues a Notice of Objections, denial or comment letter; DOB must state the grounds in writing by its 40-day review deadline (Administrative Code 28-104.2.8).
Response matrixEach comment is numbered, typed and assigned to the engineer, contractor, owner or purveyor.
Revised setSheets are revised and clouded, the calculation is re-run on the final layout and the sign detail is updated.
ResubmittalThe revised sheets, the full calculation and the response letter go back together in the agency’s format.
Re-review decisionDOB within 20 calendar days (28-104.2.9); a New Jersey construction official within 7 business days (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.16(a)); the Baltimore City Fire Department within the 5 to 10 business days it publishes.
The re-review clock starts when the revised set is filed: as of November 2026, DOB must act within 20 calendar days of a resubmission (Administrative Code 28-104.2.9) and a New Jersey construction official within 7 business days (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.16(a)), while Pennsylvania, New York State and Delaware set no separate resubmission clock.

Which sprinkler review and resubmission clocks apply in each jurisdiction?

No code gives a design team a deadline to answer a sprinkler comment, but each jurisdiction sets the clock the reviewer works to and the point at which an idle application lapses. The table gives the code, the reviewer and notice, and the review and resubmission rules for each jurisdiction DGA works in. In Maryland, the county building permit reviews sprinklers to NFPA 13 (2019) through the 2021 IBC, while the State Fire Prevention Code (NFPA 1, 2024) references NFPA 13 (2022).

JurisdictionCode and NFPA 13 editionReviewer and noticeReview and resubmission rule, as of November 2026Source
New York City2022 New York City Construction Codes; NFPA 13 (2016) as modified by Building Code Appendix QDOB, SP work type in DOB NOW: Build; Notice of Objections. The Fire Department of the City of New York (FDNY) reviews sprinkler systems for hazardous and combustible material storage.Complete application decided within 40 calendar days, extendable once by 20; written grounds for a rejection; resubmission decided within 20 calendar days; application abandoned 12 months after submission unless diligently pursued after a rejection, or 90 days after a notice that it is incomplete.Administrative Code 28-104.1.1, 28-104.2.3 and 28-104.2.7 to 28-104.2.9
New York State (outside New York City)2025 Uniform Code (2024 International Codes); NFPA 13 (2022)City, town or village code enforcement official; in Nassau County the County Fire Marshal also reviews fire protection plansNo statewide review or resubmission clock; delay is appealed to a regional board of review when an official fails to act within a reasonable time.19 NYCRR 1203.3(a) and 1205.3(a)(2)
New JerseyUCC on the 2024 International Codes, effective August 17, 2026; NFPA 13 (2022). A complete application filed under the prior codes through February 17, 2027 stays on the 2021 IBC and NFPA 13 (2019).Fire protection subcode official reviews; the construction official grants or denies the permitApplication decided within 20 business days; resubmitted plans within 7 business days; a failure to act is deemed a denial for appeal to the Construction Board of Appeals.N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.16(a) and 5:23-3.17
PennsylvaniaUCC on the 2021 International Codes since January 1, 2026; NFPA 13 (2019)Municipal building code official or third-party agency; L&I where the municipality has opted out; the Philadelphia Department of Licenses and Inspections for a Fire Suppression Systems Permit in eCLIPSE. A denial names the noncompliant elements and the provisions.Commercial application granted or denied within 30 business days, extendable by written agreement; no separate resubmission clock; where L&I reviews, a submission is returned if missing information is not supplied within 10 calendar days; Philadelphia publishes 20 business days for review with plans.34 Pa. Code 403.43(a); L&I and Philadelphia permit pages
Maryland2021 IBC through the county permit, with NFPA 13 (2019); State Fire Prevention Code, NFPA 1 (2024)County office: Montgomery DPS; Prince George’s Department of Permitting, Inspections and Enforcement (DPIE) through its Third-Party Plan Review Program; Baltimore City Fire Department; Baltimore County Department of Permits, Approvals and Inspections (PAI); the Office of the State Fire Marshal where no local office reviewsNo statewide clock. The Baltimore City Fire Department publishes 10 to 25 business days for a first review and 5 to 10 for a resubmission; the Prince George’s program sets no cap on resubmissions; Montgomery DPS takes corrections in the original folder under the original file names.Baltimore City Fire Department plan review page; Prince George’s third-party plan review manual; Montgomery DPS ePlans requirements
DelawareRegulation 701 (2026 edition); NFPA 13 (2025); IBC by countyOffice of the State Fire Marshal, through the Fire Protection Specialist assigned to the project; city fire marshals in Wilmington, Dover, Newark and the City of New CastleNo statute, regulation or State Fire Marshal page sets a review or resubmission period. The Preliminary Sprinkler Form asks for a flow test from the past 12 months on the utility’s letterhead and a demand plot that includes hose streams and the 10 psi margin.State Fire Marshal water-based submittal page and Preliminary Sprinkler Form; Regulation 702, Chapter 4

An unanswered comment stops the job. New York City issues no permit until DOB approves the construction documents (Administrative Code 28-104.1), Pennsylvania bars installing a deferred submittal, the route L&I uses for sprinkler shop drawings, until the code official approves it (34 Pa. Code 403.43(k)), and the model 2021 IFC requires fire protection shop drawings to be approved before installation starts (Section 106.2.2). Work installed ahead of approval risks rework if the comments change the layout.

A design team that disagrees with a comment has a formal route, though asking the reviewer in writing for the section behind the comment usually comes first. In New Jersey a construction official’s failure to act within the clock counts as a denial that can be appealed to the Construction Board of Appeals (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.16(a)), and Pennsylvania lets an applicant appeal the code official’s action to a board of appeals (34 Pa. Code 403.43(i) and 403.122).

How can the next sprinkler submittal avoid the same comments?

Most causes of sprinkler drawing rejections are cheapest to prevent before the layout starts. Confirm the adopted edition and the local amendments at kickoff, get the signed owner’s certificate and the storage data before the hazard classes are set, and order the flow test so it is still current on the day the working plans are filed. DGA’s article on how current a flow test must be and who can perform one covers the timing and the parties.

Before filing, check the set against the reviewer’s own list. Delaware’s Preliminary Sprinkler Form, New York City Building Code Section 903.1.2 and the Montgomery DPS NFPA 13 submittal requirements each spell out what the reviewer expects to find, from the hazard class marked on each floor plan to the DEP pressure statement and the contractor’s license numbers and expiration dates.

Then keep a margin the reviewer does not have to question. NFPA 13 sets no safety margin, but a demand point well below the supply curve survives a lower retest or a local rule such as Montgomery County’s 20 percent, while a design that touches the curve turns each water supply question into a redesign.

Key Takeaway: Sprinkler drawings are rejected when the reviewer cannot verify compliance from the set: most often a missing or out-of-date flow test, an unstated hazard or storage basis, calculations that do not match the layout, or a missing certificate, data sheet, seal or license. Sort each comment as missing information, design error, clarification or local policy, re-run the calculation on the final layout, answer every comment by number and resubmit in the agency’s format. As of November 2026, New York City DOB must act on a resubmission within 20 calendar days and a New Jersey construction official within 7 business days, while Pennsylvania, New York State and Delaware set no resubmission clock.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a resubmitted sprinkler plan take to review?

Conditional: as of November 2026, New York City DOB must act within 20 calendar days of a resubmission (Administrative Code 28-104.2.9), a New Jersey construction official within 7 business days (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.16(a)), and the Baltimore City Fire Department publishes 5 to 10 business days. Pennsylvania, New York State and Delaware set no separate resubmission clock, so the time there depends on the reviewer.

Can a reviewer reject sprinkler drawings for a flow test older than a year?

Yes. NFPA 13 limits the flow test to 12 months before working plan submittal unless the AHJ approves otherwise, in the 2022 and 2025 editions (Section 4.5.1.1) as in 2019 (4.6.1.1) and 2016 (23.2.1.1). The Delaware State Fire Marshal asks for a test from the past 12 months on the water utility’s letterhead, and Montgomery and Prince George’s counties in Maryland ask for a test within 1 year for existing buildings.

Does every plan review comment need a drawing change?

No. A comment that asks for the basis of a decision can be answered in the response letter with the section relied on, but a comment that finds a design error, or asks for an item the code requires on the drawings, needs revised and clouded sheets. Any layout change also needs a re-run hydraulic calculation so the calculation and the drawings still match.

Who answers sprinkler plan review comments: the contractor or the engineer?

Conditional: the party whose seal, signature or license is on the drawings answers, because the revised sheets go back under that name. In New York State and New Jersey that is normally a licensed engineer or architect, who in New Jersey also reviews documents others prepare and files a letter that they conform (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.15(f)); in Maryland it can be the licensed contractor’s designated qualified individual at the required NICET level, or a Maryland PE (COMAR 29.06.05.04L). Installation questions still go to the contractor.

Do third-party or peer review comments carry the same weight as the AHJ’s?

Conditional: where the AHJ runs a third-party program, the third-party review is the plan review. In Prince George’s County, Maryland, the third-party reviewer’s approval certification letter is the plan approval, so its deficiency report is answered like an AHJ comment letter. A peer review that an owner, insurer or lender commissions outside such a program reports to that client and does not approve or reject a permit.

This article is general information, not a substitute for a project-specific code analysis. Code editions, local amendments and reviewer practice change; confirm the adopted code and the authority having jurisdiction for the project.

Were the Sprinkler Drawings Sent Back?

Send the comment letter, the drawings and the hydraulic calculations. DGA sorts the comments, revises the set and the calculations or checks the contractor’s revisions, and drafts the response for resubmittal. Project briefs get confirmation and preliminary code feedback within one business day.

Send a project brief → View third-party review

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Quick inquiry

Ready when you are.

Your name, a way to reach you, and where the project is. A licensed PE replies within one business day. Every inquiry is confidential.

Prefer to describe it first? Open the Project Desk

FirmDGA Fire Protection Engineering
SheetFP-5196
OfficesNew York · Harrisburg · Seattle
LicensedNY NJ PA MD DE WA OR FL
Rev11.2026
Sheet index